since part of this was already posted, here's the rest to clarify:
<HY> I've just realized something. Plot in SDM worked because it was all linked to the female lead (Remi), after a route-lock. There was one story, they had to follow it. PoG worked because there was a purpose 'be a pirate' which came first to facilitate any interaction with characters. ADP's plot doesn't work because there is no purpose but 'stay alive.'
<HY> ha, I guess my Renko really was right. You need purpose.
<HY> Purpose, it's all about narrative purpose
<HY> This is a valuable lesson.
>>68980 <MissIzayoi> make a bad end!
<MissIzayoi> Yuka goes inside. Renko tries to kill her. But Ebolanon stands between them...
<HY> Bad Ends don't work Saguya, they just condition Anon into picking 'safe' options in working towards their goals. Their agenda is still the same.
<HY> Some types of story simply won't work in this format.
<HY> Because when conditioned right, Anon can do better.
<HY> Look at RaAN
<Kapow> we're heroic in RaAN
<Kapow> it's hard to make decisions to be weak and irrational
<Kapow> actually, those are kind of things that result from not making clear decisions
<Kapow> the whole process of decision making runs counter to the mental processes of the character you want to write
<HY> Yes Kapow!
<HY> Exactly.
<HY> This was doomed from the start.
<Kapow> I think people are still enjoying it, though
<Kapow> even if it isn't going the way you imagined
<HY> Perhaps, but it still needs intensive care.
<UBOA> if you tell them yourself in plain english that you're pissed off with how they're acting and threaten to drop ADP I doubt they'd keep it up
<Kapow> it's still not going to be easy to decide to act like someone who's weak and doesn't make clear decisions
<HY> Plus the total lack of narrative purpose!
<HY> I fucked up too.
<Kapow> they'd be kind of lost, I think, and things would start to get weird and incoherent
<Kapow> if anon can't vote to try to solve problems, they may just end up voting against solving them
<Kapow> or picking the option that would have the most entertaining bad outcome
<HY> I think I've just realized the other reason SDM worked. Short updates.